Scientific Compassion
Scientific Compassion is a project of Scientific World Changing who's goal is to use evidence-based methods to inspire a more confident, compassionate, rational community whose members want to help the world.
Friday, 1 February 2013
Video EA content
Monday, 21 January 2013
Givewell
There are many different levels of being effective in our giving. Not all charities are created equal. To do the same thing, some might spend hundreds while others might spend thousands. No one wants to donate to ineffective charities, but how do we determine a good cause from a bad one? Luckily this problem has already been addressed by a new and growing website called "Givewell".
Givewell has strict methods for evaluating and ranking charities as is laid out on their website.
Their general approach is to first review as much information as they can on the subject matter relating to charities in a certain area (e.g. different ways to treat/prevent HIV). The second step is to try and find as many charities as they can to review them. Next they evaluate them some basic criteria to rank them from most to least promising. Finally they go through the most promising ones and try to do an in depth review “through phone calls with charity representatives; reviewing internal documents including monitoring and evaluation reports, budgets, and plans for using additional funding; reviewing independent literature and evidence of effectiveness of the charities' programs”.
Givewell gets high praise from other philanthropists and activists in the field because of their rigorous scientific methodology. An excerpt from their website below explains their criteria for choosing a charity:
“We primarily look for charities with strong documented track records, highly cost-effective activities, and concrete needs for more funds. Recommended charities must be highly transparent and accountable, i.e., willing to share enough in-depth information about their work that we can assess them on these criteria.”
In essence, Givewell has something that most other charities evaluators lack; they look at the total amount of good done instead of just looking at a simple metric like overhead (how much the charity spends on things outside of the intervention such as staff and marketing). This allows them to come to much better conclusions than most others.
Sunday, 13 January 2013
Compassion and Effective Giving
In this blog I plan on talking about effective donations, philanthropy, utilitarianism and other such interesting and world-changing topics.
The first things I will cover are compassion and what I mean by effective giving, because they are such important parts of what this blog is about.
Compassion
Compassion, the desire to help those suffering, is the driving force in much of the positive actions that take place in the world today. When people heard about the tragedy of Haiti or the call of Kony 2012, it was compassion that motivated people to donate. Compassion is one of the most heartwarming parts of humanity and very important for making the world a better place, but it alone does not lead to effective giving.
Effective Giving
What is effective giving? In this blog I will define giving in a very general way, it can mean donating money, time, or picking an ethical job.
Being effective at this is simply doing this well. It comes down to trying to best answer the question, “How can I help the most people?”. To do this it is essential to use science and reason to try to come to the best conclusion you can. This blog will be focused on answering these and related questions.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)